In three tear locations in weight-bearing conditions, experts evaluated the stress distribution through longitudinal and radial meniscal tears and sought to use it to ascertain the effect of tear location and type on the potential for healing of meniscal tears. The stresses on the tear surfaces under weight bearing were influenced by both the type of meniscal tear and its location within the meniscus. Results demonstrated an agreement of the results with the clinical observations. The reasons for the inverse association between longitudinal tear length and healing, the inferior healing ability of medial vs lateral menisci, and the superior healing ability of radial tears in the posterior segment of the lateral meniscus vs other radial tears are suggested by the results. Findings suggested a likelihood of the meniscal tear location along with type to play a crucial role in dictating the success of non-operative treatment of the menisci. They suggested a probable use of it in the decision making regarding conservative or surgical management.